A 19% better checkout, in five moves

Today's Alcohol Industry Insider Newsletter

What's inside:
🔁 Sales and Retention Ideas: Fix the checkout rules that are blocking your own buyers
🛠️ Try These Tools: Ask Your Club Database Questions in Plain English With Commerce7's MCP Server
🛠️ Try These Tools: Turn your longest distributor email thread into a one-page brief, inside Gmail
🥊 Wrong Take: Stop grading your year on volume. Grade it on contribution margin.
🥊 Wrong Take: Price cuts won't fix your Gen Z problem. Comfort might.

Fix the checkout rules that are blocking your own buyers

1. Strip the billing address out of your online checkout. Commerce7 reports on its own blog that its V2 checkout, which omits the billing address, converts 19% higher than V1, and 14 months of its data showed no significant fraud difference between orders with and without it. Ask your DTC platform which version you're running. Moves conversion rate.

1. Turn on Apple Pay and Google Pay this week. Commerce7 says 13% of its orders already use them, and those also skip the billing address. A DTC lead can do it in an afternoon. Moves conversion rate.

1. Pull every declined or errored checkout from the last 90 days and have someone call or email those people. Commerce7 notes that real customers sometimes hit a "token" error when fraud rules err toward caution. Moves recovered revenue and reorder rate.

1. Route high-value orders to human review instead of a hard block. Commerce7 has tested exactly that with wineries. Moves AOV.

1. Chase card updates two weeks before each club run, not after the charge fails. Moves club churn.

Start with the declined-order list. It's free and the money is already yours.

Ask Your Club Database Questions in Plain English With Commerce7's MCP Server

Commerce7, the DTC platform a lot of wineries run their club, ecommerce, POS, and reservations on, released a Model Context Protocol (MCP) Server. In plain terms, it's a doorway that lets an AI assistant work inside your Commerce7 account the way an integration partner's software would. Commerce7 says more than 60 tools sit behind it, covering seven areas of the platform: CRM, club and subscription lifecycle, marketing campaigns, promotions, customer billing, and more.

Once it's connected, you type what you want and the assistant carries out the steps. Commerce7's own examples include "Tag all customers who visited the tasting room last weekend and spent over $200" and "Pause all shipments for members in Texas until next Tuesday due to the heatwave."

Who it's for: DTC leads, club managers, and tasting room managers at wineries already on Commerce7. If your GM asks for "top members who haven't bought a case in a year" and that question costs you 40 minutes of filters and exports, you're the target user. Breweries, distilleries, and shops running a different commerce platform should ask their vendor whether an MCP server is on the roadmap, since this is the pattern every CRM is moving toward.

A first job to try this week: before your next release, ask the assistant to build a segment of members who skipped their last two shipments and have not visited the tasting room in 12 months. That is your save list. Have it tag them, then write the hold-or-swap offer you send before the cards run. Second job: have it pull a guest's full purchase history 20 minutes before a 2:00 PM appointment so your host walks in knowing what they bought last time.

Cost: Commerce7 plans are Lite at USD $59 a month (up to $100K annual DTC revenue, 0% transaction fee), Basic at USD $149 a month (up to $600K, 1.5%), Pro at USD $399 a month (up to $4M, 1%), and Experience at USD $1,249 a month (1.5% to 0.75% fees as listed), read on commerce7.com/pricing on 2026-10-15. The pricing page does not say which plans include MCP access, so ask your account rep in writing before you budget. On the AI side, Claude Free is $0, Pro is $17 a month with the annual subscription ($200 billed up front) or $20 billed monthly, read on claude.com/pricing 2026-10-15.

The catch: this is not a toggle you flip from the dashboard. Commerce7 says a partner or a developer at your winery connects the AI tool to the server once. After that, anyone on your team can use plain language, but you need that one setup. And give an assistant the ability to pause shipments, edit billing, and merge accounts, and you want a rule about who is allowed to ask it to do what. Start with read-only questions ("who, how many, how much") for two weeks before you let it change a single record.

Call your Commerce7 rep this week and ask two questions: is MCP available on my plan, and who sets up the connection.

Turn your longest distributor email thread into a one-page brief, inside Gmail

What it is: Google has extended Gemini across Gmail, Drive, Docs, Slides, and Chat so it can run cross-app jobs from wherever you're already working. Per the Google Workspace blog, you can ask it in Gmail to turn a long thread into a structured Doc with goals and next steps, point it at a Drive folder and get a built-out spreadsheet, draft and send a recap email from inside Docs, or turn a written proposal into a deck. It pulls context from the files, emails, and chats you select, or that your admin has enabled.

Who it's for: Anyone whose business already runs on Gmail and Drive. DTC leads, tasting room managers, national sales managers, shop owners, and distributor reps who live in their inbox.

The first job to try: Open the longest email chain you have with your distributor from the last 60 days and ask Gemini in Gmail to produce a one-page brief: what was agreed, pricing and program commitments, open questions, and next steps with owners and dates. A brewery can run it on a chain-account thread, a distillery on a multi-state compliance chain, a retail shop on a vendor negotiation, and a distributor rep on the supplier thread before a ride-with.

Cost: From Google's pricing page, read 2026-10-15: Business Starter is $7 per user per month and lists the Gemini assistant in Gmail plus chat with Gemini. Business Standard is $14 per user per month and lists the assistant in Gmail, Docs, Meet, and more, which is the tier that matches this workflow. Plus is $22. A promotion running Oct 29, 2026 to Jan 29, 2027 shows $4.90, $7.00, and $15.40 respectively; the page notes the introductory price applies to new customers, the first 20 users, for 12 months. All plans are billed monthly in US dollars, 1-year commitment saves 16%, and there's a 14-day free trial.

The catch: Gemini only sees what's inside your Workspace. If your orders, club roster, and depletion numbers sit in Commerce7, VinoShipper, or a distributor portal, you'll have to export them into Drive first. Google's post also notes some of this is still rolling out and doesn't say which plan gets each new capability, so trial it before you buy seats on the strength of one feature.

Start with one thread this week, then check every dollar figure and date in the brief against the original emails before you forward it to anyone.

Stop grading your year on volume. Grade it on contribution margin.

The settled position deserves a fair hearing. Volume has been the industry's scoreboard for decades because it works as shorthand: barrels and cases are countable weekly, they absorb fixed costs, they buy you glass and can pricing, and they buy you attention from a distributor who has more brands than reps. When volume grows, almost everything else gets easier. So when craft beer posts a third straight year of declining volume, the reflex reading is a category in decline, and the reflex fix is to chase cases back with discounts, new SKUs, and more accounts.

Here is where that breaks. Volume tells you how much moved, not whether any of it paid you. Matt Gacioch, staff economist at the Brewers Association, makes the point in The New Brewer (September/October 2026, adapted on brewersassociation.org): in the association's Financial Benchmarking study of 2025 data, the median gross profit margin on beer production was 35% while the median operating profit margin was 14%. His line is the one to tape to the wall: "producing beer profitably is not the same as operating a profitable business." A brand can look fine in a keg and lose money in a can. One account can carry a territory while the account next to it quietly eats your freight budget.

The other reflex, raising price to fix the gap, has the same problem. Gacioch notes craft beer is only somewhat price-inelastic, so a price increase will very likely cost you demand.

The honest counterargument: volume still matters, and Gacioch says so. Scale lowers cost per unit, and a low-margin product can earn its place as a loss leader when it pulls people into your taproom or tasting room where the money actually is.

So keep the volume report, and put a second number next to it. Calculate contribution margin (selling price minus the variable costs of that sale) for every product, package, and channel, then weight it by your real sales mix. A winery does this across club, tasting room, and wholesale. A distillery does it across bottle sizes and control states. A retail shop does it by category and by shelf. A distributor rep does it account by account before renewing a program.

Then stress it: what happens at 10% less volume, or 5% higher input costs, and which of your expenses are genuinely variable if the year goes sideways. Do that this month and your next pricing argument stops being a guess.

Price cuts won't fix your Gen Z problem. Comfort might.

The standard explanation for Gen Z's weak craft numbers is solid, and I want to give it its due. Younger drinkers have less spending money. Many of them care about wellness and act on it. They socialize less often than earlier young adults. And their drinking occasions have shifted toward flavored beverages and RTD cocktails. A piece in the Brewers Association's The New Brewer, originally titled "Understanding Gen Z," notes that a consensus has formed around exactly those causes. All of it is true, and none of it is worth arguing with.

Here is where it falls short. Those four forces hit beer, wine, and spirits alike, yet craft beer took the harder hit. Something beyond price and calories is at work.

The argument in that same piece is that craft culture itself stopped matching the audience. Craft sold openness to new experience, self-expression through work, and creative rebellion, values built on a belief that your own choices shape your life. Research by Christina Elson and Kylie King at Wake Forest University, cited in the article, found that "Millennials are grittier and more optimistic than Gen Z," and that Gen Zers "demonstrate a weaker internal locus of control and lower self-efficacy." Louise Perry, writing in The New York Times in January, made a similar point about why the Harry Potter franchise stopped connecting with the same cohort. When a customer doubts their choices move the needle, a brand built on creative rebellion reads as somebody else's story.

What Gen Z appears to want instead is comfort, contentment, and fun. That is a merchandising instruction, not a philosophy.

So stop leading with the boundary-pushing release. Lead with the familiar thing done beautifully, then use comfortable cues (including 1990s nostalgia, which the piece flags as strong with this group) to carry the unfamiliar one. A brewery puts the lager first and the barrel-aged oddity second. A winery stops opening with soil type and opens with the occasion. A distillery sells the highball before the single barrel. A shop builds an endcap around "you already know you like this." A distributor rep pitches the safe SKU as the door opener.

Pull your top 10 sellers this week and rewrite every description to lead with familiarity. See what moves.

From the Editor:

I am always open to consulting, implementation, or brainstorming sessions. Just respond to this email, and I will get back to you shortly.

Alcohol Industry Insider Newsletter: the three-times-a-week growth newsletter for wine, beer, and spirits businesses that need smarter marketing, better sales, practical AI tools, and clear ideas they can implement now.

By Jeremy Young: serial entrepreneur, growth marketer, wine critic, and beverage industry insider.

Respond to this email with questions, ideas, or opportunities, and I will get back to you shortly!

Until next time,
Jeremy

Share This Newsletter

If you found this content useful, please share it with your colleagues and friends…

Your personal link (every colleague who subscribes through it counts toward your rewards):
👉 https://alcoholindustryinsider.com/subscribe